Training Cause vs. Effect
Dad-joke incoming…
How many martial artists does it take to change a lightbulb?
100.
1 to get it done, and 99 to say, “That’s not how we do it in our style.”
This (bad) joke highlights a common source of debate in the martial arts community, rooted in a misunderstanding.
When viewed superficially from the standpoint of “techniques,” different martial arts styles can seem vastly different. However, when viewed from the perspective of “technique,” focusing on the underlying principles, they’re really all the same.
That said, the distinction between “technique” and “techniques” plays a pivotal role in shaping training methodologies, philosophies, and, ultimately, long-term progress. This distinction is particularly relevant in the context of I Liq Chuan, The Martial Art of Awareness.
GM Sam Chin’s father, Sijo Chin, Lik-Keong, The Founder of I Liq Chuan, used to tell his students, “I’m not going to teach you techniques. If you want techniques, pay me just $1 each; I’ll teach you a million, but you won’t dare use a single one.” Why, you might ask? Because no technique works (with a high success rate) without the underlying technique.
Confused? Lemme explain:
Socrates, regarded as the father of Western philosophy and critical thinking, emphasized the importance of questioning and dialogue in seeking truth and understanding.
A key aspect of the Socratic method involves starting by clearly defining terms. This helps ensure that everyone in a discussion shares a common understanding and can engage in meaningful, productive dialogue. This foundational step is crucial for dissecting complex ideas and arriving at well-reasoned conclusions.
With that in mind, before we delve deeper, let’s first define our terms:
- Technique: This refers to how little a trainee deviates from the optimum movement pattern dictated by first principles, often associated in Chinese martial arts with the Dao (道). The Dao signifies the universe’s natural way or path, emphasizing harmony with natural laws.
- Techniques: These are pre-choreographed responses to specific cues or actions by the opponent. They are practical applications taught to address specific scenarios.
Grammatically:
- “Technique” is used as a singular, uncountable noun, indicating a general concept or quality that can’t be divided into separate items.
- “Techniques” is used as a plural, countable noun, referring to multiple specific items or instances of actions that can be enumerated and described individually.
In summary, while “techniques” refers to individual movements or actions that can be taught and executed, “technique” refers to the overarching principles and quality of movement that guide how those actions are performed.
The Case for Training Techniques
When considering the approach of training techniques, we see a method designed for efficiency and practical application, especially useful in scenarios where time and resources are limited. This approach is particularly advantageous in environments such as military training, where recruits must quickly learn the fundamentals of hand-to-hand combat.
Advantages of Techniques-Oriented Training:
- Scalability: With a limited number of instructors and a large group of trainees, teaching specific techniques allows for a standardized training program that can simultaneously be administered to many individuals.
- Time Efficiency: In settings where time is of the essence, such as military boot camps, techniques provide a quick and effective way to impart essential skills. Trainees learn specific responses to common scenarios, allowing them to be as battle-ready as possible quickly.
Case Example: Law Enforcement Training
I want to relay an anecdote here from my own experience. When I went through training for auxiliary law enforcement, empty hand restraint techniques were only one part of overall defensive tactics, which also included using the baton and proper handcuffing techniques.
Defensive tactics in turn were only one subject taught in the compressed, intensive academy which also included subjects like civil rights and legal requirements for the use of force, and so on.
Within the full scope of martial arts, the few basic “come along” techniques (basically joint locks, or chin na (擒拿) being taught only represent a fraction of the potential grappling repertoire.
When GM Sam Chin was here in 2022, we taught an eight-hour workshop on the fundamentals of Chin Na within I Liq Chuan, and we still barely scratched the surface.
Grappling, in turn, is only one category of possible techniques used in hand-to-hand combat (which also includes kicking, striking, and wrestling).
Considering the setting’s limitations, it would make no sense, nor would it have been feasible, to get lost in the intricacies and nuance of proper technique. In this scenario, just giving the recruits a handful of three—and four-step reliable techniques was not only the most sensible approach, but it was also the only viable option.
Limitations of Techniques-Oriented Training:
While training techniques offer significant advantages, particularly in terms of scalability and efficiency, they also come with notable limitations. The most significant drawback is the vulnerability of conditioned responses.
When trainees rely heavily on pre-choreographed techniques, they may struggle to adapt when faced with unexpected or novel situations. Combat is inherently unpredictable, and opponents often do not follow the script. This can leave trainees conditioned to respond in specific ways at a disadvantage when their expected scenarios do not play out.
Additionally, a keen opponent can exploit reflexive responses developed through techniques-oriented training. An observant adversary can anticipate these predictable reactions and use them to set traps or manipulate the trainee into vulnerable positions. For instance, if a fighter consistently counters a particular attack in a certain way, a savvy opponent can feign that attack to provoke a predictable response and then capitalize on the opening created. This predictability can be a significant liability in a dynamic and fluid combat situation.
Unlock your full potential with our personalized in-person and remote coaching programs—join me and take the first step on your journey to mastery!
The Technique-Oriented Approach: First Principles
In contrast to techniques-oriented training, the technique-oriented approach focuses on mastering the principles of movement, often referred to as “shen fa” (身法), or lik hok (力学) in I Liq Chuan and can be translated as “body method, or “mechanics” or “study of force.” In martial arts, these terms refer to the understanding and application of physical principles, such as leverage, balance, and motion, and the method of body movement and posture that aligns with natural principles of human physiology and efficiency.
This approach, rooted in the first principles of human movement, emphasizes understanding and internalizing the optimal mechanics dictated by our morphology and the Newtonian physics of the known universe.
Understanding The Dao: Morphology & Physics in Martial Arts:
- Morphology: This refers to the structure and form of the human body. Understanding how our body moves and operates is crucial in mastering martial arts techniques. It involves studying biomechanics, joint alignments, and the natural range of motion.
- Physics: The laws of physics, such as inertia, momentum, leverage, and gravity, play a fundamental role in martial arts. By aligning movements with these principles, martial artists can achieve maximum efficiency and effectiveness.
Advantages of Technique-Oriented Training:
- Adaptability: By focusing on first principles, trainees develop a deep understanding of the mechanics of movement. This allows them to adapt to a wide range of situations and opponents, as they are not confined to pre-set responses.
- Efficiency: Mastering the optimal movement patterns ensures that every action is performed with maximum efficiency, reducing wasted effort and energy.
- Higher Skill Ceiling: The technique-oriented approach allows for continuous improvement and refinement. As trainees gain a deeper understanding of the principles, their skills can evolve and reach higher levels of mastery.
Training the Cause, Not the Effect:
In I Liq Chuan, the focus is on training the “cause” rather than the “effect.” This means that instead of learning specific techniques (effects), trainees work on developing the underlying principles (causes, i.e., lik hok 力学) that make those techniques effective. Grandmaster Sam Chin often uses the analogy of eating (the cause) to be full (the effect) to illustrate this concept. Eating is the fundamental action that leads to the desired result of fullness, just as mastering movement principles leads to effective martial arts techniques.
This approach is both the superpower and the kryptonite of training in I Liq Chuan. The superpower lies in the depth and adaptability it provides. By understanding and internalizing the fundamental principles of movement, practitioners can respond effectively to a wide range of situations. They are not limited to pre-set techniques and can adapt fluidly to the dynamics of a real combat scenario.
However, the kryptonite of this approach is that training the cause doesn’t look like training the effect. This can be confusing and counterintuitive for beginners who are used to seeing immediate, tangible results from learning specific techniques. As GM Sam Chin says, “Eating doesn’t look like fullness, but you have to eat to be full.” In other words, the process of mastering the principles (eating) may not resemble the final, polished techniques (fullness) that students aspire to perform. This can make the training process seem obscure or frustrating for those who are accustomed to the immediate gratification of learning and practicing distinct techniques.
For instance, when training in I Liq Chuan, students might spend considerable time working on seemingly simple exercises to refine their understanding of balance, alignment, and sensitivity. These exercises might not look like traditional martial arts techniques, but they are essential for developing the core skills that will later manifest in effective techniques. This foundational work ensures that when a practitioner applies a technique, it is executed with precision, efficiency, and adaptability that would not be possible without this deep, principle-based training.
Ultimately, this approach cultivates a deeper, more intuitive understanding of martial arts. It enables practitioners to move beyond rote memorization of techniques and towards mastery of the principles that underlie all effective martial arts movements. While the path may seem longer and less direct, the end result is a more profound and versatile skill set that allows martial artists to adapt to any situation with confidence and efficacy. (In truth, this approach is the most direct path to mastery; it only seems less direct. You have to reach the inflection point in your training when “the penny drops.”)
Limitations of Technique-Oriented Training:
Despite its many benefits, the technique-oriented approach also has its challenges.
- Individual Attention: This method requires much more personal attention from instructors. Each trainee’s progress must be monitored and guided to ensure they internalize the principles correctly. (In I Liq Chuan, we say, “The art must be fed through touch.)
- Obscurity of Training Methods: The training methods can seem obscure and difficult to grasp for beginners. Without the immediate gratification of learning specific techniques, staying motivated may be challenging for some trainees.
Unlock your full potential with our personalized in-person and remote coaching programs—join me and take the first step on your journey to mastery!
Techniques Are Just Keys; Technique Is the Master Key:
Techniques can be likened to individual keys, each designed to open a specific lock. In contrast, technique is the master key that can be applied universally, capable of adapting to any situation.
Over time, martial artists come to realize that quality trumps quantity. As Bruce Lee famously said, “Fear not the man who has practiced 10,000 kicks once, but the man who has practiced one kick 10,000 times.”
From Techniques To Technique: The Evolution of Martial Arts Practice
In practice, the journey from learning “techniques” to mastering “technique” is a natural progression for most long-term martial arts practitioners. Beginners often focus on accumulating techniques, driven by the desire to know “what’s next?” This approach helps them build a repertoire of responses and gain an immediate sense of practical skills. However, as they advance, most practitioners gradually focus on understanding the “why” and “how” behind their movements. Understanding from the outset that focusing on the principles is the ultimate goal can save beginners a lot of wasted time constantly chasing after “what’s next” and instead shift focus to “what’s happening right now.”
What Is The Best Approach To Training Martial Arts?
The suitability of focusing on techniques versus technique depends on the context. On a short timeline, especially for beginners or situations demanding quick readiness, focusing on techniques is generally most appropriate. Teaching a beginner a handful of techniques provides a simple matrix to establish context and build a foundation. Even without a specific deadline, this initial focus can help new practitioners gain confidence and competence.
Ultimately, a technique-oriented approach is the final destination of all masters. Masters continuously refine their understanding and execution of principles, striving for perfection in every movement. This deep, intuitive grasp of technique enables them to adapt fluidly and effectively to any challenge.
Advanced Techniques are Just the Basics Done Better:
In his book on Aikido, Roy Suenaka wrote, “Advanced techniques are just the basics done better.” This sentiment underscores the philosophy of continuous refinement that characterizes a technique-oriented approach to training. In Chinese martial arts, this focus on the continuous refinement of basics is referred to as jibengong (基本功).
Grandmaster Sam Chin often compares the training process of I Liq Chuan to peeling an onion. The goal is not to accumulate more and more techniques or forms, but to peel away the excess until we reach the very core, or essence, of the principles. He emphasizes, “You must keep on looking at it until the nature (Dao 道) itself speaks to you.” This process of refinement and deepening understanding is what ultimately transforms a practitioner from a beginner focused on quantity to a master dedicated to quality.
Conclusion
In summary, both the techniques-oriented and technique-oriented approaches have their merits and limitations. Techniques-oriented training is highly efficient and scalable, making it ideal for large groups and time-constrained scenarios, such as military training. However, it is limited by the rigidity of conditioned responses and the risk of predictability being exploited by observant opponents.
On the other hand, the technique-oriented approach, grounded in first principles, offers adaptability and a higher skill ceiling but requires more individual attention and can be challenging for beginners to understand.
For practitioners of I Liq Chuan, the important takeaway is that whenever I refer to “technique,” I am talking about mastering optimum movement patterns rather than pre-set responses. By focusing on the causes of effective movement, we can achieve a deeper, more adaptable skill set that transcends specific techniques and allows for continuous growth and improvement in the martial arts.
Read More!
- Bruce Lee’s Real Fights: The True Stories Behind the Legend
- The Ultimate Guide To Focus Mitts & Thai Pads For Martial Arts
- Technique vs. Techniques in Martial Arts
- Is Strength Training Good For Martial Arts?
Disclaimers & Conflicts of Interest
I am not a doctor, and the information provided should not be considered medical advice. The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be used as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Consult your doctor or a qualified healthcare professional before making any changes to your diet, exercise routine, or lifestyle.
Please note that some of the links provided in this content may be affiliate links, meaning that I may receive a small commission if you purchase through them. However, please rest assured that any products or services recommended are based on my personal experience and belief in their value. I only recommend products or services that I have personally used and believe in.