Posted on

Tim Cartmell | From Kung Fu Nerd To BJJ Superstar

Tim Cartmell

East Meets West: A Journey To Mastery 

Tim Cartmell is a martial arts maestro with a journey that spans continents, styles, and decades. Where tradition meets modernity, Tim stands as a bridge between ancient practices and contemporary combat sports; he is a renowned martial artist and author known for his expertise in Chinese martial arts and achievements in Brazilian Jiujitsu, with several influential books to his name and numerous championships in submission grappling. From the quiet discipline of Taiwan’s traditional Kung Fu schools to the adrenaline-charged world of Brazilian Jiujitsu, Cartmell’s story is one of passion and a relentless pursuit of mastery. 

The Old Masters guarded their secrets closely, revealing them only to a chosen few, so the journey to mastery is rarely straightforward. Cartmell’s experiences offer a unique perspective on the evolution of a modern martial arts master. But how did he bridge the gap between these diverse disciplines of traditional martial arts and modern combat sports? What challenges did he face, and what drove him to embrace such varied forms of combat? And perhaps most intriguingly, what can we learn from his experiences that might reshape our own pursuit of martial arts? 

photo credit https://grounddragonma.com/

Tim Cartmell’s Humble Beginnings

“I started in a Chinese martial arts style called Kung Fu San Soo (功夫散手) when I was just a boy,” Tim began. His soft-spoken voice and mild mannerisms hide his deadly abilities. Beneath his slender frame lay a deep well of fighting expertise. The transition from San Soo to the “internal styles” of martial arts was a quest for deeper understanding; he explained, “The idea of maximizing your body power, the intent and those kinds of things… it seemed very developed in the internal styles,” an assessment I completely agree with.

There’s a certain magnetism to the old tales of martial artists who, in search of mastery, make the pilgrimage to distant lands. Tim Cartmell took me on one such odyssey. “I was getting out of college. And I decided I wanted to further my training, and I wanted to travel.” 

Tim’s inspiration drew from Robert Smith’s classic books. “I’d read Smith’s books, like ‘Masters and Methods‘ and was very interested in…going back to China to train, you know, at the source kind of thing,” he shared. Surprisingly, despite being deeply invested in martial arts, he had “never seen any of the internal styles live,” apart from a fleeting Tai Chi demo. 

Iron Sharpens Iron – Tim’s Time In Taiwan

Tim Cartmell’s experiences in Taiwan unravel like silk delicately drawn from a cocoon, interspersed with dedication and serendipitous meetings. I probed, “So, who did you primarily train with during your time in Taiwan?” Tim took a moment, memories flooding back, “I had quite a few teachers.” He began detailing his experiences, notably with Xu Hongji in Shenlong Tang Shou Dao Xingyi (神龍唐手道 形意拳). This wasn’t just any school – it was a fight school, giving Tim an immersive dive into San Da (散打) tournaments.


What Is San Da?

I often like to describe San Da as “3/4 MMA.” It ingeniously combines the rich legacy of Chinese martial arts with the modern demands of full-contact fighting. While emphasizing strikes, takedowns, and throws, it stops short of the ground-fighting element commonly found in full mixed martial arts. This unique fusion offers fighters a space where traditional Kung Fu techniques meet contemporary combat sports’ intense, fast-paced arena.

Throughout my journey in the martial arts world, I’ve had the privilege of competing in San Da tournaments throughout the US. San Da stands out as a stellar ruleset; it crafts fast-paced bouts that are exhilarating for both the fighters and spectators alike. A unique aspect of these tournaments is the “lei tai” (擂台) — a raised platform on which the combat takes place. The absence of ropes or cages introduces an additional strategic element: fighters can win not just by strikes or throws but also by pushing their opponent off the platform, adding another layer of excitement to an already thrilling contest.

image credit: http://www.sanda.nl/sanda.html

He painted a vivid picture: “The training was very…there was a lot of conditioning, and then we did the traditional Xingyi.” The element of sparring stood out – they sparred in every class, constantly pushing their limits. His voice hinted at a fond nostalgia when he spoke about the school’s emphasis on sparring and competition, a combination not frequently found in traditional martial arts training.

Tim’s story turned poignant as he revealed Xu Hongji’s passing after just a few months. But, true to his commitment, Tim continued for another three years under Xu’s son, deepening his roots in the same esteemed lineage. “I’d never seen a Xingyi class or a Bagua group before I went,” he confessed, underscoring his leap into the unknown with an insatiable thirst for authentic martial arts.

As he delved further, names like Chen Zuozhen, Lin Ahlong, and Luo Dexiu rolled off his tongue, painting a vibrant picture of masters and styles that contributed to his evolution. His encounter with Dan Miller opened doors to the mainland, where he connected with famed martial artists, notably Liang Kequan. 

My eyes were drawn to an exquisite calligraphy piece adorning his backdrop. “I was gonna ask you if that calligraphy on the wall was by Liang Kequan?” I inquired. 

Tim shook his head with a soft smile, “No, this is Sun Zhijun. He was widely recognized as the greatest living Bagua master and also a master calligrapher.” Although Tim’s sessions with Sun were limited, he commissioned a piece of art from the legendary figure. “That’s my favorite poem,” Tim mused, nodding towards the artwork. 

From Kung Fu San Soo to Modern Fighting Techniques

When Tim Cartmell first stepped foot in Taiwan, he was, by all accounts, a stranger in a strange land. With no grasp of Mandarin, he was led only by his indomitable passion for martial arts. “I couldn’t speak any Chinese yet,” he admitted.

Tim’s first meeting with Xu Hongji, a revered name, bore the nostalgic essence of old-school Kung Fu movies. Tim recalled, “He told me he didn’t really teach new students anymore.” Yet, as a test of Tim’s commitment, the master invited him to join his “morning exercise” sessions at Yuan Shan. And so began Tim’s initiation.

It started with foundational exercises under another instructor, gradually transitioning into lessons directly from Xu. “One day, he said this is Pi Quan, and he showed me the first form,” Tim reminisced, a tone of gratitude evident.

Tim’s response was casual when I pressed him about the school’s emphasis on strength and conditioning. The students underwent rigorous routines, including fu hu gong (伏虎功) derived from judo. Long and grueling classes involved warm-ups, judo-derived exercises, standing postures, forms, and sparring.

Beyond Xu Hongji, Tim’s journey in Taiwan connected him with several notable martial artists. Luo Dexiu, a name I was familiar with, stood out. However, it was Chen Zhouzhen who piqued my curiosity. Tim described him as an influential figure who introduced him to Hebei Xingyiquan and an older, medium-frame version of Yang Taiji.

Venturing Into The Heartland of Kung Fu

The journey to mastery is seldom linear. Such was the story of Tim Cartmell, who took a serendipitous detour into mainland China inspired by an unplanned connection. “So I traveled there a couple of times,” he began, emphasizing that his initial ventures into China were solely exploratory.

Meeting Dan Miller, the man behind the well-researched Bagua Journal, changed everything for Tim. Miller’s search for a translator collided with Tim’s by now, linguistic prowess and interest. “Dan came and was looking for a translator,” he revealed. Their subsequent travels exposed Tim to the inner circles of China’s martial arts landscape, where traditions, skills, and legacies intertwine.

With his deep connections, Miller provided Tim access to many of the biggest names practicing traditional arts on the mainland. It was this newfound exposure that anchored Tim’s resolve. “That’s when I met the teachers and decided to go to the mainland and train,” he reflected.

While Tim’s time on the mainland wasn’t continuous, it was intense and transformative. “I’d stay for a couple of months, then go back and work and train. I did that a couple of times a year for about five years,” he detailed. The ebb and flow of his visits became a rhythm, with each return deepening his understanding and refining his skills.

Such intermittent immersions highlight the dynamic and unpredictable pathways martial arts can guide a practitioner down. Each journey, each connection, serves as a stepping stone, further embedding the spirit of the art in the practitioner.

Gracie In Action Tape: Tim’s Introduction to BJJ

If ever there was a testament to life’s serendipitous moments steering our course, it’s Tim Cartmell’s chance discovery of Brazilian Jiujitsu (BJJ) in a random bookstore. 

Flipping through an early 90s issue of Black Belt magazine, an obscure ad in the back caught Tim’s eye. “Brazilian Jiujitsu…real fights.” Curious and slightly skeptical, he bought the Gracie In Action tape depicted in the ad. The raw realness of the fights and the evident strategy behind them resonated with him. “I had a little wrestling experience…most fights end up on the ground,” Tim mused. 

His enthusiasm soon spread to an old friend, a formidable bouncer and San Soo fighter from Texas. Skeptical at first, his friend later took on the Gracie challenge, ending up in a quick, humbling submission by the legendary Rickson Gracie.

Tim Cartmell after winning a submission grappling match

His change of heart was complete, culminating in him training rigorously in BJJ and becoming an instructor. Afterward, he told Tim, “You know, I took one look at Rickson, And I knew I was in trouble.” “But,” he said, “in my wildest dreams. I had no idea how fast I would lose.”

Back in Taiwan, Tim’s commitment to Jiujitsu only deepened. The first UFC event proved a pivotal moment. Tim recalled, “I said the skinny Brazilian kid will win, and everyone laughed.” The world soon stopped laughing as BJJ’s efficacy was showcased for all to see.

By the time he returned to California in ’94, BJJ was taking the US by storm. Tim trained under various instructors, eventually earning his black belt from Cleber Luciana. This newfound expertise led him to compete in pro submission grappling in his 40s, a challenging endeavor.

At Shen Wu Academy in LA, Tim taught Brazilian Jiujitsu and traditional Chinese arts while introducing a unique “ground proofing” program. Disheartened by the business demands, he transitioned as a coach to ACE Jiujitsu, emphasizing competition and instruction. His deep BJJ expertise, enriched by Chinese martial arts, paved the way for his MMA coaching. Since the early 2000s, Tim has been an instrumental figure at ACE Jiujitsu, molding fighters and sharing his extensive knowledge, reflecting his own path and the transformative journey of a style that reshaped global fighting perspectives.

Blending Old and New: Tim Cartmell’s Insights on Martial Arts

Diving into the vast ocean of martial arts, I was curious to understand the harmony between ancient traditions and contemporary combat sports. It wasn’t about contrasting them but a genuine inquiry rooted in open-hearted curiosity.

I turned to Tim Cartmell for insights. His deep involvement in both realms made him an ideal voice. “What can each discipline teach the other?” I asked.

Tim emphasized the adaptability of MMA. “They’ll learn anything from anyone as long as you can prove it works,” he noted, highlighting its foundational principle. This isn’t arrogance but a relentless quest for what’s practical.

However, while MMA is grounded in its practical testing against skilled opponents, traditional martial arts can sometimes lean heavily into forms, missing out on the real essence of combat.

Offering an analogy, Tim remarked, “Imagine being in a boxing gym. If all you did was jump rope and hit a heavy bag, you still can’t box.” The underlying message: mere forms without the test of combat fall short.

Tim throws a student at the old Shen Wu Academy in LA.

Yet, Tim’s perspective wasn’t about discounting traditional martial arts. Instead, he pointed out the strength and wisdom they carry. While MMA fighters are unquestionably formidable in street scenarios, the mindfulness fostered by traditional arts can provide invaluable insights, especially when external factors like the environment or potential weapons are involved.

Concluding, Tim stressed the importance of intention. Being clear about your purpose is crucial whether you’re into martial arts for defense, sport, or personal growth.

Bridging Traditional Chinese Martial Arts & BJJ

My quest for understanding how traditional Chinese martial arts mesh with modern fighting techniques led me to another poignant question for Tim Cartmell. Could years of practice in the ancient arts be an asset or perhaps an obstacle in Jiujitsu?

Tim’s response was enlightening, “Absolutely. It established a discipline.” It wasn’t just the physical form but the discipline, the mind-body unity, the consciousness of movement that Chinese martial arts instilled in him. These foundational principles didn’t need to be relearned when he ventured into Jiujitsu.

He vividly drew parallels, “What we’d call in Tai Chi as ‘freestyle pushing hands’ in English, we call it wrestling.” The sensitivity, the intuitive nature of predicting an opponent’s move, was a strength Tim had honed during his years with traditional arts. Some techniques, like the throws in Baguazhang, felt familiar, even if the ground combat was new territory.

While the principles shared between the two practices were theoretically clear, their application took time to crystallize, especially on the ground. “Several years in my jiujitsu training,” as Tim recalled.

Sparring, Tim emphasized, was the laboratory of real-world application. It’s one thing to execute a move on a compliant opponent but in a live setting? That’s the actual challenge. It was in these sparring sessions that Tim could dissect what he had learned from Chinese martial arts and adapt, refine, and test them.

He pointed out the inherent limitation of traditional styles, particularly the absence of ground fighting. Although he didn’t say so explicitly, my impression was that while Tim had internalized everything of value he could from his Kung Fu days, he had largely left them behind.

A Fusion of Martial Arts Discipline and Innovation

As our conversation continued, I felt a growing sense of desperation to find some thread of Kung Fu in the combat sports champion. “How much of what you learned from your time in Taiwan and China do you still practice regularly?” I asked.

Tim’s answer was reflective yet deep-rooted in his experiences. “The body use that I learned, certain alignments and ways to coordinate your body. That’s in everything,” he explained. It was as if the foundational principles he had embraced in China and Taiwan had seamlessly blended into his current practices.

Although traditional forms weren’t a staple in his routine, he saw value in teaching them to those still interested in the old ways. Everything, from the most complex martial sequence to a simple push-up, was a form for Tim. “It’s a Kata. You should always be paying attention to your alignment, your relationship with gravity,” he asserted. 

What Breath Work Does Tim Cartmell Practice?

“Is there any type of Qigong or even breath work you incorporate for recovery or to modulate your mental state?” I inquired, searching for insights deeper than mere physical movements.

“My breath work is incorporated into everything I do,” he began. His journey into the art of breathing started young, intertwined with yoga and the varied pranayama exercises. Yet, it was evident that while the specific exercises faded over the years, the essence remained. 

He reminisced about training with Rickson Gracie, a name synonymous with ju-jitsu. “Rickson is big on yogic breathing,” Cartmell mused, delving into techniques tied to the heat of competitions, about catching your breath amidst a fierce duel. “Those things, I use when I grapple,” he said, emphasizing its significance.

Through Cartmell’s words, I was reminded that in the grand dance of martial arts, it’s not just about power and form but also the subtlety of breath. It’s a rhythm, a life force, and a strategy all rolled into one.

But what struck me most was Tim’s vision of transcending styles. “If somebody can throw a hard front kick, and they kick you in the face, can you tell what style it’s from? I think not.” There was no rigid boundary between styles for him. It was about imbibing the essence of the strategy and fluidly merging them.

Drawing Lines Between Tradition & Combat

Leaning into the conversation, “With your broad training base, how would you approach teaching someone unfamiliar with martial arts?” I inquired.

Tim’s response was thoughtful, colored by the wisdom of his experience. “I have a method broken down,” he begins. “One that I teach a lot is ‘ground proofing‘ — grappling self-defense for non-grapplers.” He paints a vivid image of an integrated system he has taught to various police departments, and throughout Europe. Tim’s perspective emphasizes efficient, real-world applications for those with limited time. “If you came to me wanting just to defend yourself in a few months,” he clarifies, “there’d be no qigong (氣功) or zhan zhuang (站桩); that’d be a waste of time.”

His answer is grounded, reflecting a philosophy prioritizing immediate need over historical profundity. However, the roots are still remembered. If a student were to immerse themselves in the art, tradition would come into play. “If you wanted to learn Xingyiquan as a traditional style, we start with standing,” Tim elaborates. 

A recurrent theme emerges: goals. He believes practices like zhan zhuang might be redundant for his MMA fighters. Yet, for someone seeking health benefits, he sees value. “It depends on people’s goals and their purpose for training,” he explains. The conversation pivots to zhan zhuang, a practice Tim regards as valuable for its myriad benefits — body conditioning to mind coordination. Yet, he notes, “the very best fighters in the world have never heard of zhan zhuang.”

It’s an intriguing dichotomy — the balance between ancient art forms and modern combat requirements. As Tim so aptly concludes, what you learn and how it aids you wholly “depends on what your goal is.”

Clearing The Air On Tai Chi

Under the digital magnification of a Zoom window, I asked Tim to expand on something he’d said at a recent Tai Chi workshop in Paris in which he’d stated that the “whole idea of Tai Chi is to get someone on one foot.” Naturally, this ruffled some feathers in the Tai Chi community, and I asked Tim to say more about it.

“Obviously, there’s a lot more to Tai Chi than putting someone on one foot,” Cartmell began, addressing the comment. 

Tim Cartmell dove into Tai Chi’s multifaceted history, its transformation from a martial art to a health regimen, offering perspectives that many might find unfamiliar. 

Referring to Sun Lutang’s work, he noted that Taijiquan’s original emphasis was on its fighting techniques. Cartmell elaborated, “One of the big benefits of Tai Chi practicing Taiji is you can learn to fight very quickly because the technique base is limited and the method is very obvious or straightforward.” This sharply contrasts with the modern perception of Tai Chi, which many see as a slow-paced, health-centric exercise shrouded in mystical elements and alleged qi powers. Contrary to Tim’s viewpoint that Tai Chi is relatively straightforward, an echo chamber exists within certain circles. This group perpetuates the narrative that “real Tai Chi” is an art so complex that its depths are only truly understood by a select, anointed few. 

He also brought up Chen Weiming’s early 1930s writings, which vouched for Tai Chi’s martial prowess. However, what really caught my attention was Chen’s observation: “Everybody knows Tai Chi is a great fighting style, but very few people know it’s good for health.” 

Cartmell went on to describe the foundational strategy of Taijiquan: to ‘uproot’ the opponent. “Uprooting is to shift their weight onto one of their feet,” he articulated. This idea was crystallized when he said, “When you push them onto one foot… they have 360 [dead angles]”. Essentially, if you can strategically shift an opponent’s weight to one foot, their balance is compromised, and they can be effortlessly toppled.

He referred to the “dead angle” – a principle I remembered from his book Effortless Combat Throws. When an opponent is balanced on both feet, they have two predictable angles of vulnerability. Move them onto one foot, however, and their vulnerability becomes infinite.

Drawing the conversation to a close, he left me with a striking metaphor, comparing the approach in Tai Chi to angling a gun: “Everything before [the fajin (發勁)] is like push hands… Once you have a superior connection, you can bring them onto one foot, and then you issue your force, and the guy falls down.” The aim is precision, not brute force.

It was an enlightening moment – understanding Tai Chi not just as a graceful dance but as a strategic art of balance and force.

Conclusion

As my conversation with the renowned martial artist Tim Cartmell unfolded, it was clear that the vast world of martial arts is as much about understanding deep-rooted theories as it is about physical practice. When asked about a book recommendation, Tim instantly brought up John Danaher and Hanzo Gracie’s “Mastering Jiujitsu” – a resource-heavy on theory, crucial for understanding the heart of Brazilian Jiujitsu. But another book that repeatedly emerges in such dialogues is Jack Dempsey’s “Championship Fighting.” Though small, it’s a core guide that dives straight into the mechanics of force generation, often likened to traditional techniques. It has been a perennial favorite amongst many of the masters I’ve interviewed and a personal favorite.

He might be flying under the radar regarding self-promotion, but Tim Cartmell’s commitment to martial arts is palpable. As our conversation wrapped up, I couldn’t help but be inspired by his profound insights, hoping for a face-to-face encounter soon. It was a privilege to have such a master share his time and perspective with me.

Join us and unlock the secrets of the Old Masters!

Read More!

About the Author

I Liq Chuan Instructor Ashe Higgs

Ashe Higgs, I Liq Chuan Master Instructor & L2 Nutrition Coach

Ashe is a highly skilled martial arts instructor and certified nutrition coach with over two decades of experience in the field. He holds a Master Instructor certification in I Liq Chuan under Sam FS Chin, making him one of only several individuals worldwide to hold the title. He has taught classes and workshops worldwide and is passionate about helping others achieve their fitness and wellness goals.

With a background in full-contact fighting and a Level 2 certification from Precision Nutrition in nutrition coaching, Ashe is a well-rounded expert in the fields of martial arts. In addition to his expertise, he has a wealth of experience in teaching and mentoring others. He has a natural ability to connect with his students and inspire them to reach their full potential.

Read more about Ashe here…

Disclaimers & Conflicts of Interest

I am not a doctor, and the information provided should not be considered medical advice. The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be used as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Consult your doctor or a qualified healthcare professional before making any changes to your diet, exercise routine, or lifestyle.

Please note that some of the links provided in this content may be affiliate links, meaning that I may receive a small commission if you purchase through them. However, please rest assured that any products or services recommended are based on my personal experience and belief in their value. I only recommend products or services that I have personally used and believe in.

Posted on

Howard Popkin & Daito-ryū

Howard Popkin

The Crouching Tiger of Daito-ryū

Daito-ryū, like a tsunami, marries the fluid elegance of water’s movement with devastating potential. Just as the ocean’s waves can transform from serene beauty to overwhelming might, the techniques in Daito-ryū can gracefully shift from subtle redirections to crashing takedowns. In both, there’s an inherent understanding of the power that lies beneath the surface, waiting for the precise moment to be unleashed. 

The Great Wave off Kanagawa by Hokusai. The power of water is a common metaphor in martial arts.

Just as a tsunami embodies the raw force of the sea, Daito-ryū represents the culmination of budō, where fluidity and devastation walk hand in hand. Within the swirling currents of Daito-ryū’s waters, a master moves silently, like a hidden dragon concealed beneath the depths. While his name may not resonate loudly in mainstream circles, he emerges with a formidable yet unassuming presence for those fortunate enough to cross his path.

Enter Howard Popkin, a martial arts instructor whose skill unfolds as a captivating dance of precision and grace, rivaled only by his unparalleled humility. While the world of martial arts often glorifies flamboyant showmen, hidden gems like Howard represent the deep-rooted spirit and essence of the way. In a landscape brimming with spectacle, known simply as “Howie” among friends, his quiet dedication and profound understanding of Daito-ryū highlight the core values of budō.

Howard Popkin and the Art of Daito-ryū

“You’re chubby, and you’re Jewish; you should learn to defend yourself,” Popkin quoted his Brooklyn-born father, whom he describes as a “realist,” explaining his initial plunge into the martial arts world. The sentiment, although humorously frank, was the spark that ignited his lifelong journey through the intricate corridors of jujitsu. Howard’s first teacher was Jeff Lovering, a local instructor who introduced him to Haku-ryū Jujitsu, an American offshoot related to Daito-ryū. “His style was very good, solid martial arts,” Popkin noted.

Howard’s journey saw him delve into judo and karate while in college before a chance encounter with Roy Goldberg. “What he was teaching at that time was… brutally effective,” Popkin said, describing a combination of jujitsu, Aikido, and other styles Goldberg was practicing. It was an eclectic blend that Popkin seemed to respect but treaded carefully around, emphasizing the importance of preserving the boundaries of each art.

These days, Howard is pretty slim.

And then there was Daito-ryū. “The system’s mechanics were very different,” Popkin admitted, explaining his draw to this particular style. Under the guidance of Okamoto Seigo in Japan, his connection to Daito-ryū deepened.

Delving Deeper: Daito-ryū and the Essence of Mastery

Okamoto Seigo, the founder of Daito-ryū Aiki-jujutsu Roppokai, hailed from Yubari City, Hokkaido, born in 1925. In 1963, he began his training under Kodo Horikawa, the founder of Daito-ryū Aiki-jujutsu Kodokai and a prominent disciple of Sokaku Takeda.

The electric hum of curiosity charged our conversation as Howard recalled his pivotal first meeting with Okamoto, the Daito-ryū master who would reshape his journey to mastery. Howard describes his teacher as “a wonderful human being, not a religious man but spiritual” with a deep love of sake. “I read about him on the internet,” Popkin begins, painting a picture of the days when the internet was still an unusual resource for such connections.

His story with Okamoto began with a simple letter translated into Japanese by a friend. Okamoto responded casually; Howard could train if he came to Japan. Without hesitation and driven by a thirst for authentic knowledge, Howard took the plunge, traveling to The Land of The Rising Sun to immerse himself in the heart of the discipline. 

Okamoto Seigo in Popkin's garage gym.
The founder of Daito-ryū Aiki-jujutsu Roppokai, Okamoto Seigo.

A Whole New World

His first steps in the dojo, however, were disorienting, to say the least. “I sat down [after class] on the side and… My father said, ‘What’s with the distressed look on your face?’” Popkin confides. His reflection on that first lesson in Japan was a mix of humility and wonder: “I just did an hour and a half of techniques… And I didn’t understand one thing the guy did tonight.”

This was the beginning of Popkin’s deep dive into the sophisticated world of Daito-ryū, an art that some compare to the “internal” arts of Chinese fighting traditions, known for their development of “unusual” power. But rather than presenting these principles directly, Okamoto’s teaching kept the secrets of the Old Masters hidden in plain sight. “Little by little,” Popkin reminisces, “once you got a handle on external motions, he would start to address ‘well, maybe try to rotate this, maybe try to lift that.'” It wasn’t a straightforward lecture on “internal” versus “external,” but an immersive lesson in feeling and understanding.

Unraveling the Mystery of Aiki

Our conversation shifted into the mysterious and often contentious realm of aiki (合気). 

  • 合 (ai) typically means “joining” or “harmony.”
  • 気 (ki) often refers to “spirit,” “energy,” or “breath.”

In the context of martial arts, “aiki” is often translated as “harmonizing,” “joining,” or “combining energy.”

To those entrenched in the martial arts world, the term aiki can spark heated debates. Some view it as a nearly mythical force, while others see it as nothing more than highly refined technique. Its definition often remains as elusive as grasping smoke in one’s hand, and indeed, many masters and practitioners hold varied interpretations.

I probed into Howard’s experiences with this concept, especially as taught by Okamoto. Howard reminisced, “There were lots of discussions around it. Every student who showed up would ask him. And he always gave the same answer; it was his ‘for public consumption’ definition.

He described it as circular motions, timing your breathing correctly, and using coordinated body movements. But it was never a definition you could really use.” 

Howard warmly remembered a signature demonstration by Okamoto. The old master would first gauge a student’s stability, ensuring their stance was firm and grounded. Once convinced, he would playfully employ the principle of rotation. Students would find themselves flying effortlessly, a profound contrast to the raw use of brute force. This wasn’t merely a display of technique; it showcased the principle of the soft overcoming the hard and the circular defeating the straight.

Okamoto demonstrates with Howard Popkin

He continued, describing the fragmented journey to mastering aiki. Okamoto used to say that any solid technique in martial arts has numerous components. Just when a student feels they’ve acquired a handful, believing they’re on the path to mastery, Okamoto would gently remind them of the vast expanse still left to learn. It was a humbling analogy: “Even if you’ve mastered 10 components, you might still be missing the other 90.”

As our dialogue continued, Howard shed light on the practical aspect of their training. Despite the language barrier – with Howard’s limited Japanese and Okamoto’s basic English – the essence of their lessons transcended words. Okamoto would challenge Howard with a barrage of techniques in a single session. Instead of drowning in the complexity, Howard focused on individual elements like footwork, expansion, contraction, or rotation. This focus helped him understand the underlying thread connecting each technique, an approach he and his long-time training partner Joe Brogna found invaluable.

Enter Dan Harden – The Ronin of Daito-ryū

Describing himself as “always one to give credit where it’s due,” Howard felt the need to pay tribute to a man named Dan Harden.

“I learned a lot of [aiki] exercises and stability training from Dan Harden,” he revealed, his voice hinting at gratitude mixed with deep respect. “I think I picked them up from him a little faster…because of my experience with Okamoto.”

“[Harden] was looking for body skills,” Howard remarked. Dan was on a quest to unlock the secrets of the Old Masters. This enigma, often articulated in Chinese as shenfa (身法) or lik hok (力学) in I Liq Chuan, went beyond mere technique or style, delving deep into the very essence and mechanism of so-called “internal “strength/aiki. Learning from Okamoto and Harden and bridging their teachings was like capturing lightning in a bottle for Howard

The dynamics between Harden’s and Okamoto’s teachings were starkly different. While Okamoto, revered in the martial arts community, often taught the unification technique from a gentle grab or push, Harden had a much more intense approach. “With Dan, there was always a ton of pressure,” Howard explained. “If you couldn’t make it work under the pressure, it was kind of useless.”.

Stand Up Guys

Interestingly, in an age of combat sports, where “jujitsu” immediately conjures images of ground fighting, Popkin clarifies that 99% of his training with Okamoto was standing up, rooted in Japan’s sword-based culture. Equally compelling was Okamoto’s gentle approach. Unlike some trainers who prove techniques through pain, Okamoto displayed his mastery with gentleness, never needing to hurt to prove a point. 

“There was never a time when he would do a joint locking technique on me where he actually would put me in pain. He would show us where it was, but he never needed to get to the point where you were tapping, or you knew your arm was gonna snap,” Popkin reflects, his voice echoing with reverence. “He was very comfortable with his abilities and knew it worked.”

Howard’s recollections of the old master remind me of my own teacher, GM Sam Chin.  Approaching 70, the old tiger remains tremendously formidable. Like a lion playing with its cub, he can unleash a display of terrifying power, turning even big guys and long-time students like me into ragdolls at will without ever causing us harm.

Delving into Daito-ryū’s Dynamics

“When most people think about soft martial arts, they think non-impact,” Howard explains. “I want to be able to use my body to develop devastating power, or devastating throwing or locking… softly.”

The term “three beers loose” floats back into my mind. A cue Howard had used during his time in Arizona, reinforcing the notion of “relaxed readiness,” highlighting the counterintuitive strength that exists in relaxation, a commonality between Daito-ryū and I Liq Chuan.

As the conversation delved deeper into the principles, Howard articulated, “Don’t meet force with force. Okamoto would move around it when met with resistance, never clashing head-on. This isn’t about avoiding contact but preventing a direct power struggle at the point of contact. A straight push, force against force, contrasted with maneuvering around or under an opponent.”

Drawing connections between Daito-ryū and I Liq Chuan, he observed, “I’ve seen similarities in your art, especially in the spinning hands videos. How you respond without directly opposing force reminds me of our principles, even if I’m just a novice in understanding your system.”

Okamoto sends Popkin flying effortlessly.

Although this last observation by Howard is debatable, I didn’t challenge him on it at the time, instead preferring to let him speak freely.  I Liq Chuan, in fact, does initially train to meet force head-on to “catch the tip of the spear,” only after which can it be redirected.  Having experienced Howard’s skill firsthand, it’s likely that, ultimately, we’re in basic agreement but using slightly different means to the same end.  It would have been a much longer conversation that would have detracted from the spotlight I wanted to shine on Howard, so I let his remark stand unchallenged.

At this point, Howard presented a nuanced observation regarding the many branches on the tree of Daito-ryū that exist today: as opposed to “one way for all,” Takeda’s teachings were tailored. Takeda, a monumental figure in the martial art’s legacy, emphasized an individualized approach to combat based on body type. Whether you were tall, stout, agile, or sturdy, he had a specific approach for you. Yet, as Howard observes, these personalized teachings often became an orthodoxy when passed down, obscuring the vicissitude of Daito-ryū’s adaptability. “People say ‘this is it.’ Well, that’s what your teacher was taught. But my teacher got taught this,” he points out, emphasizing the breadth of the art form. “So which one is it? [It’s all of them.]”

Wisdom for the Uninitiated

Having wasted many hours on dead-ends in the early part of my martial arts career, I’m always interested to hear about what unique insights others with a lifetime of experience have that can help the next generation avoid wasting their precious time. “What do you think are some of the most common mistakes that beginners make?”

With a pause that suggested years of reflection, Howard began, “I think it’s very difficult when you start taking martial arts to have any clue what you’re actually looking for.” He recalled his own fortunate beginnings,  noting, “I got lucky when I started.”  

I couldn’t agree more with Howard on this point, having myself started with I Liq Chuan belaboring under many false assumptions and delusions about the secrets of the Old Masters, and like Howard, it was only through sheer luck, or perhaps providence, that I committed myself to I Liq Chuan. 

“One of the biggest mistakes is not researching a little bit… not seeing what’s out there.” A reminder that while martial arts begins with the physical, its depth and impact on a practitioner’s life are largely influenced by the teacher’s character and the discipline’s ethos.

The Enduring Value of Martial Arts

I think, understanding that the subject would have taken us on a detour we didn’t have the time to explore, Howard switched gears to another common misstep: a shallow perception of martial arts. “Most people think martial arts is [just] punching and kicking. But there’s so much more to it than that.” His voice hinted at the vast spectrum of martial arts, stretching far beyond the visible.

I asked, “So when you say that martial arts is so much more than just punching and kicking, what do you mean by that?”

With decades of experience coloring his response, Howard shared, “The physical and mental confidence that one gets from knowing they can control a situation is tremendous.” But it wasn’t just about control. The martial arts, according to Howard, conferred a transformative calm. Laughing, Howard said, “I think you’re one of the few guys that can ‘out-calm’ me. And I attribute that entirely to our study of martial arts.”

The Virtue of Discipline, Courage & Integrity

Howard’s gaze deepened, building on our discussion about the depth and essence of martial arts beyond mere technique. “Traditional martial arts have tremendous value. First, in their ethics,” he began, “the student-teacher relationship is tremendous.” His respect for the discipline was evident. “The values imparted in traditional martial arts are also really wonderful, especially for children.”

Fascinated, I asked, “What are you doing to ensure those values are passed on to your students now?” His reply revealed a blend of modern teaching methodologies infused with the wisdom of the Old Masters. Howard spoke about a teacher from Rhode Island, Greg Horton, who had a unique method of teaching children. “His system allows you to impart the traditional life skills, so to speak, while doing martial arts,” Howard explained.

Desperate for a tangible understanding, I pleaded, “Can you give me just a small example?” He illustrated a scenario where, after initially teaching a child a stance or punch, the child is then invited to teach the same to the rest of the class. The method intrigued me. It resonated with my own approach to adult classes, giving students ownership and ensuring the art lives beyond the teacher.

Looking Back

Talking with Howard, I was struck by the depth of his journey in martial arts. Looking for additional pearls of wisdom to pass on to the next generation is asked, “If you could go back in time and talk to your younger self, what advice would you give?” I pondered aloud.

Howard quipped, “Keep your hands up without missing a beat.” A ripple of laughter passed between us, yet a more profound sentiment lay beneath that. Howard continued, “I would have met Okamoto 10 years earlier.” The note of wistfulness was unmistakable.

His deep respect for Okamoto illuminated his words. “He was such an amazing person. I would have loved to spend more time with him.”

“The price of anything is the amount of life you exchange for it.”

Henry David Thoreau

Wedding At Tokyo Station

In the glow of reminiscing about his precious time with Okamoto, Howard segued into another heartwarming tale that showcased the deep love between teacher and student. With a twinkle in his eye, he began, “I don’t know if you know the story with me and my wife…”

At a pivotal point in his martial arts journey, Howard was approaching a significant rank. In Daito-ryū, one eventually arrives at the fourth-degree black belt. Then, the master decides whether to bestow an assistant teaching license upon the student. To Howard’s astonishment, Okamoto, in a room filled with peers, announced that while Howard was ready for this elevation, he wouldn’t receive it. The reason? 

Okamoto displayed caring for his students’ happiness and well-being beyond martial arts and expressed a playful concern that Howard wasn’t married. In Japan, turning 40 and being single was frowned upon – the translator amusingly called such a man a “scoundrel,” though that might’ve been a polite substitution for Okamoto’s actual words.

Laughing, Howard recalled his rebuttal, pointing out their shared fishing and drinking adventures, activities that, he jokingly claimed, married men might find challenging. In a light-hearted dare, Howard challenged Okamoto: if he wrote a proposal in kanji saying, “Will you marry me,” he’d parade it through Tokyo Station on a T-shirt.

Joe Brogna (left) and Howard on one of their many fishing trips with Okamoto when he visited their dojo in NY.

Okamoto’s playful acceptance took Howard by surprise, but the twist in the tale is that he met the love of his life just six weeks later. While he didn’t meet her at Tokyo Station, in a gesture that spoke volumes of their bond, Okamoto’s calligraphy was almost like a talisman, catapulting his student forward into the next phase of his life as a happily married family man.

Chuckling, I responded, “That’s a great story,” a testament to the depth of respect, camaraderie, and affection between master and student.

Sacred Steps Forward: The Unforeseen Path of a Legacy

Transitioning to more recent events, I asked, “Howard, how did you begin your journey in the seminar circuit?” What unfolded was the story of an unexpected series of events, a display of the unpredictability of life, and the magnetic pull of genuine skill.

In ancient Japan, it was not uncommon for martial artists to journey through the land, driven by the quest for mastery and the lure of legendary dojos. Those were days when tales of skill became the stuff of lore, shared beneath cherry blossoms and amidst misty mountains. 

Echoing that timeless narrative, a curious Aikido-ka found his way to Howard’s dojo. The insights he gleaned there had a deep-rooted significance. At a subsequent seminar, equipped with this quiet wisdom from Howard, he caught an experienced instructor off-guard and floored him, reminding everyone of the profound power of Daito-ryū. 

That move, that singular moment of skill, became a spark of intrigue. “Where did you learn that?” the floored instructor had demanded, astonishment evident. 

“From Howard Popkin,” was the Aikido-ka’s simple yet impactful reply.

Intrigued and impressed, the seminar instructor wasted no time. He sought Howard out, eager to understand the depth of his techniques and artistry for himself. From this serendipitous chain of events, Howard’s journey took a new turn, leading him to US and UK seminars, expanding his impact far beyond his humble dojo’s walls.

Conclusion

The Depth of Discipline and the Bonds We Forge

The new Popkin-Brogna Jujitsu Center in West Hempstead, NY.

As our conversation concluded, I was struck by how intricately the martial arts journey is woven with the ties that bind us. My discussion with Howard was not just an exploration of techniques or traditions; it was a deeper dive into the profound relationships we cultivate and the meaning they infuse into our practice.

Howard’s tales, from his charming proposal story to the intricate lessons of Daito-ryū, echo a world where discipline intertwines with kinship. His journey of over 40 years on the mats is a monument to the unwavering spirit of commitment – a beacon for someone like me.

There’s genuine humility in learning from someone who has spent twice as long in the arts, witnessing the ebb and flow of tradition and evolution. I’m honored to call Howard both a friend and a mentor. It’s not just for the stories or insights but for exemplifying how relationships – with our mentors, our peers, and ourselves – deepen the significance of our lives.

His dedication inspires and reminds us of the rich tapestry of martial arts, woven with threads of knowledge, understanding, and the relationships we cherish.

Afterward – Connect With Howard

Interested in diving deeper into the teachings of Howard Popkin? Head over to his official websites, http://www.ginjukai.com/ or https://popkinbrognaselfdefense.com/, or follow the Ginjukai Facebook page.

With his long-time training partner, Joe Brogna, Howard manages the Popkin-Brogna Jujitsu Center in West Hempstead on Long Island. Though he’s taken a step back from an exhaustive seminar circuit to dedicate time to raising his son, his teachings continue to resonate.

For those eager to explore the depths of Daito-ryū, the recommended read is “Daito-ryū Aiki Jujutsu” authored by Okamoto. While it’s currently out of print, the book remains accessible on Amazon for enthusiasts and scholars alike.

Join us and unlock the secrets of the Old Masters!

Read More!

About the Author

I Liq Chuan Instructor Ashe Higgs

Ashe Higgs, I Liq Chuan Master Instructor & L2 Nutrition Coach

Ashe is a highly skilled martial arts instructor and certified nutrition coach with over two decades of experience in the field. He holds a Master Instructor certification in I Liq Chuan under Sam FS Chin, making him one of only several individuals worldwide to hold the title. He has taught classes and workshops worldwide and is passionate about helping others achieve their fitness and wellness goals.

With a background in full-contact fighting and a Level 2 certification from Precision Nutrition in nutrition coaching, Ashe is a well-rounded expert in the fields of martial arts. In addition to his expertise, he has a wealth of experience in teaching and mentoring others. He has a natural ability to connect with his students and inspire them to reach their full potential.

Read more about Ashe here…

Disclaimers & Conflicts of Interest

I am not a doctor, and the information provided should not be considered medical advice. The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be used as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Consult your doctor or a qualified healthcare professional before making any changes to your diet, exercise routine, or lifestyle.

Please note that some of the links provided in this content may be affiliate links, meaning that I may receive a small commission if you purchase through them. However, please rest assured that any products or services recommended are based on my personal experience and belief in their value. I only recommend products or services that I have personally used and believe in.